Selecting the right home exterior goes beyond looks. It’s also about protection, durability, and energy efficiency. As a Utah homeowner, you’ll come across two popular options – stucco and Hardie plank.
Both materials offer strength, style, and weather resistance. But, when you compare Hardie Board vs stucco, your choice typically comes down to what suits your local climate, budget, and maintenance. Stucco is great for a seamless, energy-efficient exterior, while Hardie plank mimics wood with extreme durability.
So, is stucco better than siding? Are you better off with a Hardie Plank? This decision is not as easy as it sounds. Let’s break it down so you can choose the right siding for your home.
What Is Stucco?
Stucco is a cement-based material applied in multiple layers to create a smooth, textured, or patterned finish. It’s a go-to option for many homes in Utah because it can handle extreme weather while offering a clean, modern look.
Pros of Stucco
- Durability: Stucco is resistant to fire, pests, and even mold. When applied correctly, it can last 20+ years with minimal upkeep.
- Energy Efficiency: Stucco naturally insulates your home, keeping it cooler in summer and warmer in winter. It reduces heating and cooling costs, which can be a critical consideration in light of the proposed 30% rate hike by Rocky Mountain Power – Utah’s primary power supplier.
- Customizable Appearance: Choose from different textures and colors to match your style. Whether you want a classic, smooth finish or a Spanish-style exterior, stucco offers great flexibility.
- Low Maintenance: Unlike wood siding, stucco doesn’t need frequent repainting or sealing. A simple wash every now and then keeps it looking great.
Cons of Stucco
- Not Ideal for Heavy Moisture: While stucco does well in dry climates, it can absorb water in prolonged wet conditions. If moisture seeps in, it can lead to cracks and damage.
- Cracking Issues: Over time, minor cracks can develop due to Utah’s freeze-thaw cycles. While small cracks are fixable, larger issues may require resurfacing.
- Higher Installation Cost: Stucco application is labor-intensive and intricate. That means you’ll need to hire the right exterior renovation contractor to get the job done. Typically, a professional install can cost $6–$10 per square foot, making it pricier than some siding options.
What Is Hardie Plank?
Hardie Plank, also known as fiber cement siding, is made from a mix of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers. It mimics the look of wood but offers superior durability and weather resistance.
Pros of Hardie Plank
- Extreme Durability: Hardie Plank can withstand harsh weather, moisture, and even impact damage. It doesn’t warp, crack, or expand like wood.
- Resistant to Fire & Pests: Unlike wood siding, fiber cement is non-combustible and resistant to termites and rot.
- Low Maintenance: A fresh coat of paint every 15+ years is usually all it needs. It also doesn’t need frequent sealing or repairs.
- Versatile Styles & Colors: Hardie Plank comes in different textures, including wood grain, smooth, and stucco-like finishes. You can also choose from factory-finished colors or paint it any shade you like.
Cons of Hardie Plank
- Installation Costs More Than Vinyl: Hardie Plank costs $8–$12 per square foot, including materials and labor, which is higher than installing vinyl planks.
- Heavier Material: Because fiber cement is dense, installation requires extra labor. It can take longer to install than vinyl or wood siding. Plus, you need to find an exterior remodeling contractor who can get the job done without damaging your property.
- Needs Occasional Painting: While low maintenance, Hardie Plank needs repainting every 10–15 years to maintain its look.
Stucco Vs Hardie Board: Which One Should You Choose?
As mentioned, when you compare stucco vs. Hardie plank, the final decision comes down to your climate, budget, and design preferences. Each material offers unique benefits, so consider what matters most for your home.
Choose Stucco If:
- You want a classic, seamless look: Stucco offers a smooth, modern finish that works well with many architectural styles, from Mediterranean to contemporary. It can be textured or tinted to match your home’s aesthetic, creating a clean, uniform look.
- Your home is in a dry, arid climate: Stucco thrives in hot, dry environments like Utah. It resists heat well and won’t expand or contract as much as other materials. However, it’s not ideal for areas with high humidity or excessive rainfall, as it can absorb moisture over time.
- You need energy-efficient siding: Stucco naturally insulates your home, keeping it cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter. This can lower energy bills by reducing the strain on your HVAC system. When combined with proper insulation, stucco helps improve indoor comfort year-round.
Choose Hardie Plank If:
- You need maximum durability for all weather conditions: Hardie Plank is resistant to extreme weather, including heavy rain, snow, and strong winds. Unlike stucco, it doesn’t crack easily, making it a solid choice for Utah’s varying climate.
- You prefer the look of wood without the upkeep: Hardie Plank mimics the appearance of wood siding but doesn’t require constant repainting or sealing. It offers the charm of wood without the risk of rot, pests, or warping, making it a long-lasting and attractive choice.
- You want low maintenance and long-term value: Hardie Plank is designed to last 30–50 years with minimal maintenance. It resists fire, moisture, and UV damage, meaning you won’t have to deal with costly repairs or frequent replacements. It’s a great investment for homeowners looking for long-term savings.
| Feature | Stucco | Hardie Plank |
| Material Composition | Cement-based mixture applied in layers | Fiber cement made from cement, sand, and cellulose fibers |
| Durability | Lasts over 20 years; resistant to fire, pests, and mold | Lasts 30-50 years; withstands harsh weather; doesn’t warp or crack |
| Energy Efficiency | Provides natural insulation, aiding in temperature regulation | Offers moderate insulation properties |
| Maintenance | Low upkeep; occasional washing needed | Requires repainting every 10–15 years |
| Cost | Approximately $6–$10 per square foot | Approximately $8–$12 per square foot |
| Appearance Options | Various textures and colors for a seamless look | Mimics wood with options for different finishes |
| Climate Suitability | Best in dry climates; may absorb moisture in wet areas | Suitable for various climates, including areas with heavy rainfall |
| Installation Considerations | Labor-intensive application; potential for cracks in freeze-thaw cycles | Heavier material; requires skilled installation |
Note: Costs are approximate and can vary based on location and specific project requirements.
Hire A Professional to Upgrade Your Home Exterior
Comparing stucco vs. Hardie Board can be tricky, but a professional can help you choose what’s best for your home. They understand Utah’s climate, siding durability, and long-term maintenance needs, ensuring you invest in the best option when upgrading your home’s exterior.
In addition to this, hiring a pro also provides:
- Proper Installation: Ensure your siding lasts with professional-grade materials and techniques.
- Climate-Specific Advice: Professionals recommend siding that withstands Utah’s hot summers and snowy winters.
- Custom Design Options: Match colors, textures, and finishes to enhance your home’s curb appeal.
- Long-Term Savings: Avoid costly mistakes and repairs with expert installation and guidance.
Get The Exterior Your Home Deserves
Both materials are great choices for Utah homes. When upgrading your home exterior, you want a long-lasting, low-maintenance, and good-looking siding solution.
If you’re unsure which of these two fits your home best, we can help. Our experts will guide you in choosing the perfect exterior for your home.
Contact us today to get your FREE BID!
